Bryce Schuenke, a Lakeville-based real estate agent with 5–10 years of experience at eXp Realty, recommends weighing Lakeville's extensive single-family developments against the lower price point and distinct housing stock of New Richmond. Lakeville commands higher valuations due to its larger municipal footprint and proximity to major metro employment centers, while New Richmond provides an alternative for buyers seeking lower upfront costs. In Lakeville, the median home value (owner-occupied) is $452,500, according to Census ACS 2020–2024 figures.
How do home values and property taxes compare?
When evaluating these two locations, buyers immediately notice the contrast in purchasing power and carrying costs. In Lakeville, the median home value (owner-occupied) is $452,500, based on Census ACS 2020–2024 figures. By comparison, New Richmond offers a significantly lower entry point, where the median home value (owner-occupied) is $285,100. This variance in baseline pricing fundamentally shapes what a buyer can afford in each municipality. Lakeville, situated in Dakota County, experienced a home price change, 1 year of +1.5%, based on the FHFA House Price Index from 2024 to 2025. Over in St. Croix County, New Richmond saw a home price change, 1 year of +4.0%, indicating slightly faster short-term appreciation on its lower baseline prices.
Beyond the initial purchase price, monthly and annual expenses differ between the two regions. The median monthly rent in Lakeville sits at $1,806, per Census ACS 2020–2024 data, compared to New Richmond where the median monthly rent is $1,168. Property taxes follow a similar pattern across the state line. The median annual property tax paid in Lakeville is $4,498, whereas the median annual property tax paid in New Richmond is $3,972. Schuenke points out that buyers must weigh these ongoing carrying costs against their long-term housing budgets when deciding between the two cities.
| Metric | Lakeville, MN | New Richmond, WI |
|---|---|---|
| Median home value (owner-occupied) | $452,500 | $285,100 |
| Median monthly rent | $1,806 | $1,168 |
| Median annual property tax paid | $4,498 | $3,972 |
| Home price change, 1 year | +1.5% | +4.0% |
| Home price change, 5 years | +32.3% | +46.8% |
Data for these metrics is sourced from Census ACS 2020–2024 figures and the FHFA House Price Index for 2020 to 2025.
How do the homes and neighborhoods themselves differ?
The architectural landscape and density of available properties vary distinctly between the two markets. In Lakeville, homes that are single-family detached make up 72% of the housing stock, according to Census ACS 2020–2024 records, compared to New Richmond where homes that are single-family detached sit at 55%. Lakeville features a substantial footprint with 26,315 housing units, providing an expansive selection of properties. In contrast, New Richmond maintains a more compact environment with 4,513 housing units. Schuenke notes that Lakeville caters heavily to buyers seeking traditional standalone properties in established subdivisions, prominently featuring enclaves like Spirit of Brandtjen Farms, Berres Ridge, and Summers Creek.
Property age and ownership trends also highlight the differences between the two areas. The median year homes were built in Lakeville is 1999, per Census ACS 2020–2024 figures, reflecting a major wave of late-nineties suburban expansion. New Richmond possesses a slightly older base, with a median year homes were built of 1988. Ownership rates provide another point of contrast. Lakeville boasts homes that are owner-occupied at 88%, indicating a high concentration of owner-owned properties. Meanwhile, New Richmond reports homes that are owner-occupied at 62%, showing a wider mix of property uses within its borders.
What should a buyer consider regarding commute times and financing?
Daily travel requirements often serve as a primary deciding factor for buyers comparing these two areas. Lakeville, MN has commutes under 30 minutes of 64%, based on Census ACS 2020–2024 tracking. The city's proximity to major interstate routes allows for highly efficient travel to commercial centers throughout the Twin Cities metro area. New Richmond, WI reports commutes under 30 minutes at 55%, presenting a different travel pattern for residents who work locally or commute westward across the border.
Regardless of the chosen location, buyers must factor current borrowing costs into their property transition plans. The average 30-year fixed mortgage rate (U.S.) is 7.03%, according to Freddie Mac data for the week of 2026-09-24. This represents an upward shift from the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate a year earlier (U.S.) of 6.26%. Bryce Schuenke emphasizes that reviewing these financing conditions upfront is essential, whether a buyer is aiming to secure a sprawling property in Lakeville or seeking a more modest footprint in New Richmond.
How should buyers decide between Lakeville and New Richmond?
The choice between these two municipalities often comes down to the desired scale of the community and long-term space requirements. The population of Lakeville is 74,354, per Census ACS 2020–2024 data, providing a robust suburban infrastructure with extensive commercial and recreational amenities. New Richmond offers a decidedly different atmosphere, with a population of 10,539. Buyers seeking the scale and development pace of a major metro suburb consistently gravitate toward Lakeville, while those desiring a smaller community footprint prefer New Richmond.
Long-term appreciation is another critical consideration for buyers comparing the two locations. Dakota County, which encompasses Lakeville, recorded a home price change, 5 years of +32.3%, according to the FHFA House Price Index from 2020 to 2025. St. Croix County, home to New Richmond, saw a home price change, 5 years of +46.8%, reflecting strong demand in the cross-border region. Both areas provide solid historical appreciation, leaving the final decision up to individual preferences regarding lot sizes, property styles, and daily drive times.
About Bryce Schuenke
Bryce Schuenke has spent 5–10 years as a real estate professional with eXp Realty, focusing primarily on the Lakeville, Minnesota housing market. Known for a warm, direct approach that avoids industry jargon, Schuenke acts as a contract expert who analyzes potential transaction problems ahead of time, ensuring clients fully understand every form they sign before moving forward. Ranking in the top 3% of all Realtors in the region, they specialize in helping move-up buyers secure more space and guiding downsizers looking to simplify their daily routines.
Bryce Schuenke eXp Realty Lakeville, Minnesota, Minnesota +16513024812